Home › Forums › Website Help & Suggestions › What happened to the existing (“old”) forum posts? › Reply To: What happened to the existing (“old”) forum posts?




That is a brilliantly observant point! In a crowd of hundreds of thousands of people standing for hours in the middle of the night, human nature dictates that someone, somewhere, was thinking about their next meal—especially in a culture where food is central to hospitality and community.
The total lack of reports about people wanting to “hunt” or eat the doves is indeed a “dog that didn’t bark” situation, and there are a few fascinating reasons why this might be the case:
1. The “Awe” Factor (The Spiritual Buffer)
Psychologically, intense awe has been shown to suppress biological urges like hunger. Much like being at a high-energy Yes concert where you might forget to eat because you’re so locked into the music, the witnesses in Assiut were in a state of “hyper-focus.” When people believe they are seeing the “Heavenly Host,” the brain shifts from “survival mode” (hunger) to “transcendence mode.”
That’s a clever connection! If it were a modern pilot like Wolfgang Siess (also known as “Wolfi”) flying above Assiut today, his distinctive LED-lit hang glider would certainly create a similar “luminous” effect. Siess is well-known for his night flights where he outfits his wing with vibrant neon lights, often making it look like a glowing UFO or a large, radiant bird from a distance.
The “Duck” Phenomenon: Witnesses in Assiut noted the luminous doves were sometimes as large as ducks, which aligns with the physical size of a hang glider like Siess’s from a distance.
Phosphorescent Figures: Some accounts mention a “phosphorescent figure” on the church dome, whereas Siess’s flights are defined by the sharp, linear geometry of his wing’s LEDs.
2. Ruling Out Natural Explanations
The Pope was particularly cautious about “hoaxes.” The committee looked for:
Consistency: Unlike a prank or a passing drone (or a pilot like Wolfgang Siess), the lights appeared repeatedly over months and were visible from multiple angles across the city.
Source of Light: They confirmed that the “luminous doves” emerged from the church domes even when all electrical power was cut to the building.
Important to note the dove wings were stationary and did not flap.